Sit In Kayak Vs Sit On Top Kayak

Sit Inside Vs Sit On Top Fishing Kayaks: The Winner Is?

Sit Inside Vs Sit On Top Fishing KayakFloating on the water makes you feel good, whether you are swimming, surfing or paddling a kayak. If you like it most when on a kayak for fishing or recreational activity, then you are yet to be in for a dilemma. When shopping for a kayak, you have a variety to choose. For this, you need a clear guideline to enable you to pick the one that suits your interests the most. Making a mistake when shopping is something we all dread.

To ease your shopping choices, it would be nice if you knew whether you like a sit inside kayak or the sit on top one. Both of them have extreme strengths that entice you and may confuse you. Knowing their weaknesses helps you in eliminating them and leaves you with the best you can handle. Below, I have discussed the two kayaks, including their pros and cons.

Sit Inside vs Sit on Top Fishing Kayaks

Sit On Top Fishing Kayak

Sit On Top Kayaks

Just as the name suggests, you get on the kayak and sit on a designated seat, without a cockpit. It is common among anglers. It is also a good one for professional activities like surfing and diving. Under normal circumstances, there are models accommodative to one person, two and three. Usually, they are suitable both in coastal and inland waters. Below, I have discussed pros and cons of this once a traditional sit-in-boat.



Their hulls are very wide, thus making it quite unlikely to flip because of the winds. In case it overturns, and you are in the water, it is so easy to flip it upright and get back on. Do you want to stand when fishing? Do it! Its design can withstand rough conditions at sea.

Sufficient gear space with easy access

There is a storage compartment for coolers, fish and angling gear behind your seat. Therefore, you can put what you need for the whole time you are ashore. The level of this spot is the same as your seat, making it easy for you to turn and access them.

Easy to enter

There is no closed cockpit, therefore to get onto your kayak, you hop on it and occupy your seat. Your feet have a comfortable place to rest, and that base is very relaxed. Once you are done and you are back to the shores, you will just hop off as if you are climbing down a stair.

It is self-bailing

In case water joins you on board, you need not worry; keep fishing. The kayak is a hollow tube, designed with scupper holes that automatically drain water when it gets into the kayak. This saves your time and effort. You are in a position to just fish without worrying about water filling up your spot.


The wind affects you

You will be openly exposed to the atmosphere, and you are guaranteed to feel the effect of wind on you. It could make you cold or uncomfortable. Nevertheless, there is a solution to this; add an anchor stake or use a rudder at the back of your kayak to track better on water.

A wet ride

Waves and rains will hit you directly. There is no shelter provided for you so that you will receive all the water there is around you. You shall, therefore, need to be well dressed for the occasion. If there were a closed cockpit on it, you would have had some bit of protection from water.

Tedious transportation

With all the stability comes weight. The design of this kayak is elaborately efficient, but to get to this, there is addition of some massive weight. It gives you the extra work of hiring kayak carts to haul them over land. It is more daunting to transport them than it is for sit inside ones.


Sit Inside Fishing Kayak

Sit Inside Kayaks

This type of kayaks is a grand development to suit your needs. It has a cockpit where you get into and sit. The foot paddles are inside the cockpit, and its very comfortable seat is an enticement. The sizes range from slim and long to short and eclectic. They are very good for recreational activities as well as fishing. A paddler desiring protection from certain harsh weather conditions will be delighted at it. I have listed pros and cons of this type of kayaks below.


Lightweight and portable

The cockpit design gives you room for transportation since you can place it on your shoulder and move about with it. The weight does you a big favor here. It is light, and whether short or long, you get the advantage of saving on transportation cost. You can do it yourself.

Shield from winds

The cockpit provides you with some protection from robust winds. The sides of the hulls keep you somehow guarded. The existence of this cockpit inside lowers the center of gravity of your kayak, hence enabling you to keep fishing in windy conditions without being blown around. Paddling becomes easy.

Warmth in the cold

It may get chilly, but this kayak has got you covered. When we jog some basic physics in our minds, we know that air is commendable as a thermal insulator. For this reason, the air in the hull traps warmth from your body, thus protecting you from the cold outside. If you love fishing in the winter, get yourself this kayak.


Insufficient space

You will occupy most of the availed space in the cockpit, leaving limited space for your fishing gear and trawl. Some of the sit inside kayaks have storage compartments set aside. These, however, are placed in such a way that accessing them is not as easy as you would have desired.

Difficult to board

The fact that you have to enter the kayak in itself is tiring. Your feet must get into the cockpit to get to the paddles. Whenever you are through with your expedition, exiting it is another hustle. In the case that your kayak has overturned, you will flip it upright but boarding it again becomes difficult.

Water is confined

When paddling, a minor wave is likely to hit you, and the sturdy kayak will sail through it. However, water may spill into your space. These kayaks are not built to withstand this; therefore, your comfort is compromised. You will have to fetch this water manually and throw it into the rest of the water. You will eat into your fishing time for this.

It is hotter when hot

Air is a noble thermal insulator, and for this, it can be to your disadvantage too. If it is sunny and scorching, your cockpit gets stuffy, and you sweat a lot. The heat your feet releases are trapped within, making the whole experience very unworthy.


In Conclusion

It is up to you to settle for your most suitable fishing kayak. A sit on top kayak is so common among trawlers, especially in the warm weather, as compared to a sit inside kayak. They are easy to paddle, stable, and voluminous. They give you all the room you need for fresh air. Sit inside kayaks, on the other hand, can be used in the winter. Their ability to create a mini-environment for you is a plus. As a kayaker, reward yourself with a kayak worthy of your gracious self. As for the winner, you tell me.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.